Another reprint from the past, but still true!
Today is the Feast of All Soul’s Day in the Catholic Church. It’s one of only 2 days when priests are obligated to say three Masses – the other one’s Christmas – meaning you should probably show up even though it is not a HDO and you just went yesterday.

My Baptist/Non-Denominational/But Definitely Not Charismatic, aka “Generic Christian” husband just doesn’t get most Catholic holidays, but this one in particular flummoxes him. Today we go to Mass to pray for the dead. Not in a Witch of Endor divination kind of way, but in a “Go Team Go” kind of way. We’re not looking for lotto numbers or the name of our future mate, we’re asking God to have mercy on them.
See, Catholics, like most Christians, believe in an immortal soul. They also believe that when someone dies, just because they are separated from their body does not mean they have no idea what’s going on down here on earth with the rest of us mortals. Scripture tells us that the angels in Heaven rejoice when even one sinner repents. (Luke 15:10)
Catholics believe the Saints in Heaven are rejoicing too, especially the souls of that sinner’s family and friends, who knew and loved him on Earth. This is why Catholics pray to the Saints – we ask them to pray for us, just like we would ask our neighbor or parishioner to pray for us. Except they pray for us literally in front of the throne of God. (Rev. 6:8-10)
We pray today for the dead in Purgatory. Purgatory is another Catholic doctrine that Luther wasn’t too fond of and got rid of when he decided to invent his brand of cafeteria Catholicism.
Basically, Catholics believe that sin marks your soul. Makes it look like the undercarriage
of your car after a jaunty 4-wheeling adventure. (Catholics also believe that Baptism leaves an indelible character on your soul, forever marking you as belonging to His Church). We don’t believe that we are a dung heap covered with a blanket of snow, as it were. If that were the case, well, there’d be a lot of cr** in Heaven, covered or not, which doesn’t make much sense because we know that everything in Heaven is perfect – not just masked or covered. (Rev. 21:27)
Catholics believe that Christ actually forgives and forgets, and the marks caused by sin are actually removed. Our souls, in Heaven, are actually snow white through and through, not just a thin layer. We are made perfect. (Heb 12:23)
Often, sin has a great impact both externally and internally. We have do penance and make reparation in order to actually get all the grubbies off our soul. Scripture constantly exhorts us to repent. We can ask for forgiveness and receive it, but if you’ve ever been a teacher, you know that sometimes there’s residue left over even after erasing.
Purgatory is the stopover to perfect our souls before we are admitted to the Beatific Vision. Kinda like the Lion in the Wizard of Oz got his hair curled and beribboned before getting an audience with the big Kahuna. Purgatory is not a second chance – if you die condemned, then, well, you’re condemned, and we all know where that leads. Straight down.
Catholics also believe that no man is an island… we’re all in this together. Just as St. Paul beat his flesh and suffered to make up what was lacking in the body of Christ, His Church, our suffering isn’t wasted. (Col. 1:24) We can offer it up in place of the penance and purgation (hence the word, Purgatory) our brothers and sisters in Christ should suffer. We can help a brother out. (As St. Paul did, 2 Tim 1:16-18)
And nothing helps out the suffering souls like a Mass offered on their behalf. So go to church today. If you can’t make it, at least take the example of the children of Fatima, and do some small penance. If you don’t have a hair shirt, put a rock in your shoe. If you can’t go on bread and water all day, skip meat at one meal or pass over dessert. For a real penance, make brownies and give them all away without even licking the spoon. And don’t forget to offer it up!
DISCLAIMER: This is not an exhaustive theological dissertation. But I can give you links for some if you’re interested.
(This first appeared on my Blogger site, November 2006)

















{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }
Really excellent.
If I get around to putting up a post of my own tonight, I’m linking to this if you don’t mind.
I love the analogy of the lion in the Wizard of Oz. It reminds me of how, in the OT, the kings bride would spend a while (months I think) having various beauty treatments before the wedding.
Name your baby before you post, LOL!
This is what I believe on behalf of loved ones “seeing us from Heaven.”:
http://www.gotquestions.org/heaven-look-down.html
And also, what the Bible says about “praying for the dead.”
http://www.gotquestions.org/praying-for-the-dead.html
I know some of it is vague in some way, especially the first topic, but praying to the dead seems kind of pointless… JMO.
It’s not pointless. We know that they are not gone- their souls live on. We know that what we do on earth affects souls and angels in heaven (per Matt 18:9-11, Luke 15:10)
The site you linked is a little confusing- it says there will be one judgement, yet goes on to describe two judgements (one immediately after death, and then of course the one when the world ends as recorded in Revelations.) I found the points in the article to be confusing. But I really think the difference lies in the definition of salvation and a misunderstanding of why we offer our prayers for the dead. It’s not so that they’ll be saved, if they’ve already been condemned. I’d point you to my article, but you’ve already read it.
Actually, I believe it’s thanks to you that I “grok” the Catholic doctrine of Purgatory. Leaning more and more Catholic these days.
@ycw,
If you ever have any questions let me know. If I don’t know the answer I can find it for you or point you in the right direction.
OH! I always wondered about that.
So what do you mean by Cafeteria Catholicism?
Please keep these kind of posts coming as I am hesitant to ask my Catholic in laws because often they don’t know the answer to my questions and sometimes they think my interest means I want to convert.
I’d love to particularly hear more about the rosary.
Thanks!
“Cafeteria Catholicism” is when you pick and choose which doctrines you’re going to believe or follow. For example, someone might choose to follow the Catholic teachings on Mary’s place in the salvation story, but ignore the Church’s teaching on going to Mass. Catholicism doesn’t work that way. If you believe the Church has the Truth – then you have to accept all of it. It’s not a Luby’s where you can decide you don’t want a side of chastity today.
But Martin Luther started his own church didn’t he, once he posted the list of complaints (so to speak) on the church door, he was pretty much saying he was no longer a Catholic, right?
Can you explain also, while we are on the subject, about saying a mass for departed loved ones. Does the family have to pay for this? Is it the same concept as praying for already passed loved ones?
Thank you!
Masses are offered for the departed. It is traditional to give the priest a stipend to cover the cost of candles, etc. used in the Mass but there’s no set fee and certainly many priests offer Masses with no money changing hands. Often people will put Mass requests into the offering basket when it is passed around. The Mass is the official and ultimate, infinite prayer of the Church.
I don’t think Luther intended to start his own church. At the time, he just wanted to change the Catholic church or at least that what it seems from the histories I’ve read. hy Originally he sent a letter to his bishop protesting what he saw as abuses (he was a theology scholar). Interestingly, most non-Catholic Christians who celebrate Reformation Day don’t actually believe what Luther believed. Years after posting his 95 theses he got excommunicated, started his own church and ended up breaking his solemn vows and running off with a nun.
Ah! Very interesting!
Great post!
{Don’t get discouraged by folks that come to debate the Catholic Faith!}
Peace in Christ,
Georgiann
{ 2 trackbacks }